Roots & Riddles is a storytelling podcast that digs deep into the forgotten corners and unsolved puzzles of Fillmore County, Minnesota. Hosted by Lenora and Preston, each episode unearths a tale where history meets mystery—from chilling crimes and vanished towns to skyward dreams and roadside riddles.

Listen Now!

Available on any of your favorite Podcast platforms:

• Amazon Music
• Apple Podcasts
• Castbox
• Goodpods
• iHeart Radio
• Overcast
• Pocket Casts
• Spotify
• YouTube Music

A Deadly Teenage Rivalry in Rushford – Roots & Riddles

In the early morning hours of September 15, 1951, 19-year-old Doelan Peterson was shot and killed outside a Rushford home. The person holding the rifle was 16-year-old Carrol Bakken—and at the center of the story was a 15-year-old girl both boys knew.Within hours, Bakken had signed the first of two statements describing firing at Peterson from just four feet away. But when the case reached a packed Fillmore County courtroom, the story became far less straightforward. The defense argued the shooting was an accident, challenged Bakken’s confessions, and pointed to a broken piece of the rifle as evidence of what may have happened that night.Was Peterson deliberately shot in a fit of jealousy, or did a confrontation between teenagers end in a tragic accident?This week on Roots & Riddles, we revisit the shooting, the controversial confessions, the dramatic murder trial, and the verdict that left Rushford divided—and ultimately prompted the community to take action for its young people.

1. A Deadly Teenage Rivalry in Rushford 23:44
2. Two Fillmore County Boys at Gettysburg 23:53
3. Did the Legend of Freddy Krueger Start in Wykoff? 17:53
4. The Mystery of Wykoff’s John Doe 22:39
5. Wykoff’s Imaginary Murderer 21:23

The idea for the podcast was born from Legacy Lane’s own family history research, which uncovered countless captivating stories tucked away in dusty archives and fading memories. These discoveries sparked a desire to share and preserve the region’s rich heritage—not just for one family, but for the whole community.

Blending meticulous research with narrative warmth, the show invites listeners to rediscover the people, places, and events that shaped southeastern Minnesota—some legendary, some long buried, and all worth remembering. Whether it’s a saloon robbery in Fountain or a sky-hopping pioneer in Cherry Grove, every story reveals a thread in the fabric of the past.

Roots & Riddles is a proud production of Legacy Lane Genealogy, committed to preserving local heritage through compelling audio storytelling.